Death Cab For Cutie – Live At Red Rocks 2015-07-15

Soul Meets Body as Benjamin Gibbard and the iconic indie-pop band enthrall the faithful in a sold-out show at Red Rocks.

Red Rocks Amphitheatre is one of America’s very best concert venues and a personal favorite. Just outside Denver, Colorado in the town of Morrison, Red Rocks is a natural amphitheatre with sandstone walls that create a tremendous sound environment and is hollowed out with great sight lines to the stage.

STSIW - DCFC - Red RocksSTSIW - DC - Red Rocks cover

On a gorgeously clear mid-summer night under the stars on July 15, 2015, the stage was set for a magical night with Death Cab For Cutie in front of an ecstatic crowd of mostly young, mostly female adherents after an enthusiastic opening set by tUnE-yArDs and their blend of polyrhythms and vocal effects.

DCfC is an excellent and underrated live act and their fans are some of the most ardent in music. They seem to fill the same places emotionally to their audience that The Cure filled to an earlier generation. On their first major tour since 2012 to promote the new outstanding “Kintsugi” album, DCfC drew from all stages of their surprisingly long career and rich catalog (eight studio albums) going all the way back to 1998’s Something About Airplanes.

Ben Gibbard’s voice, equal parts Neil Young and Neil Finn, is a wonder – plaintive, open and expressive while simultaneously holding a hint of bitterness and threat that combine to make a romanticly dangerous, or dangerously romantic, combination of obsessivesness, melancholy and sweetness. The lyrics are thoughtful, literate and full of longing but with a bit of an edge that keeps them more edgy than maudlin.

In concert, Gibbard bobs and weaves like a boxer in front of a double mike setup that includes his vocal looping kit used on tracks like “You Are A Tourist” and periodically moves back to the piano. Nick Harmer on bass prowls his part of the stage like a panther and Jason McGerr on drums pounds out a surprisingly sturdy rhythm for a pop band.


Dave Depper on guitar/keyboards and Zac Rae on keyboards/guitar fill out a deceptively lush sound. Gibbard keeps the between-song patter to a minimum which services the carefully crafted set list to move between moods and emotions without a break. His playing showed no ill effects from the wrist injury he suffered this spring.

Kintsugi is an ideal metaphor for DCfC’s music, so ideal that if it didn’t already exist someone would have had to invent it. Kintsugi is the Japanese art of repairing broken pottery using gold, silver or platinum as the interstitial. The idea is to celebrate brokenness and highlight the beauty of being broken. We are all broken people in one way or another and kintsugi highlights the beauty of the brokenness unique for every individual, telling the story both of the breakage and the repair.


Without being too heavy-handed here, that’s a great description of DCfC’s songs as well, particularly the ones on Kintsugi.   As Gibbard approaches 40, it’s hard not to focus on whether the lyrics apply to Gibbard’s recent divorce from Zooey Deschanel and the rebuilding of his life since then, but the tie is inescapable on lyrics such as “Black Suns line “How could something so fair/Be so cruel”.

Although Kintsugi’s songs are largely somber, melancholy and wistful, there is also passion and beauty in the lyrics, music and singing that both revels and reveals pain while searching for beauty. This is Night Music that you play to acknowledge Pain before the Dawn you know is coming.

Here’s an example from the show off Kintsugi, the understated “Little Wanderer”…

DCfC’s music is more complex and brooding than typical indie-pop and I was impressed that the crowd seemed to fall right in on some of the complex pieces. An example is “I Will Possess Your Heart”, to me one of the best songs of the past decade and which opens with 2:00 of feedback and squall led by Gibbard with Harmer locking down the bass, followed by another 2:00 of piano moodsetting over the driving beat before any vocals kick in.

I Will Possess Your Heart builds a tension/release like the best of drone blues from the American South with the pressure gradually building and building to a fever pitch before the constriction gets released as the vocals begin, after which the song is actually just beginning. Not your typical radio-friendly indie pop, and it really is something of a revelation live…

Other highlights of the show included a skronking version of “The New Year”, the driving pulse and riffs of “You Are A Tourist”, and the pallet cleansing of the acoustic interlude for “I Will Follow You Into The Dark”, to which the entire audience sang along note for note like it was a Dashboard Confessional emo concert.

Videos for all three songs below:



Other than I Will Possess Your Heart, the high point for me was their usual set closer, a transcendently romantic and crystalline version of “Transatlanticsm”. Transatlanticism is one of my all-time favorite songs, and I’m always amazed by how moving the music and simple lyrics like the repeated “I need you so much closer; Come on now” refrain can tug at your heartstrings.

No video of Transatlanticism here because I put the phone down, got in touch with my inner tween girl and lost myself singing along with the crowd. Every once in a while you have to do things like this to not only remind you that you’re alive, but why you’re alive.

As they left the stage at the end of Transatlanticism, Gibbard flipped me his guitar picks and the evening was complete.   The teenage version of me would have been happy to skip life and proceed directly to Heaven from that point. No-longer teen-age me wouldn’t quite go that far, but it was still a reminder of the power of music to move the spirit. We all need that reminder from time to time. Thank you DCfC.




  • No Room In Frame
  • Crooked Teeth
  • Why’d You Want To Live Here
  • Black Sun
  • The New Year
  • The Ghosts Of Beverly Drive
  • Grapevine Fires
  • Little Wanderer
  • No Sunlight
  • Company Calls
  • President of What?
  • You’ve Haunted Me All My Life
  • What Sarah Said
  • I Will Follow You Into The Dark (acoustic; solo)
  • Everything’s A Ceiling
  • You Are A Tourist
  • Doors Unlocked And Open
  • Cath…
  • Soul Meets Body
  • I Will Possess Your Heart


  • Passenger Seat
  • A Movie Script Ending
  • The Sound Of Settling
  • Transatlanticism


Album Review: The Vaccines – English Graffiti

I mostly listen to music through headphones and whilst my current set are not studio quality, they’re decent enough to cope with any type of music and give a good listening experience.  So I was surprised when I hit play on English Graffiti, the third studio album from The Vaccines. It was so loud that I had to swiftly remove the headphones for fear of damaging my hearing, but checking the volume, it was on my normal setting.

Start again – still too loud. Turn down volume, that’s better. But wait –  it still sounds too loud, so loud in fact that the sound is all distorted. Only it’s not loud anymore, just distorted. Something is wrong with my headphones, try another set – just the same. Must be the device? Try another device – still the same.

After skipping through a few tracks I  came to the conclusion it must be a flawed download or something. Almost every track sounded heavily distorted, as if it had been recorded with the meters in the red the whole time. The bass is hard to hear, lost under a hail of distorted drums and guitars.

Here’s one of the worst offenders

I did a quick internet search to see if there was a known problem with the download. But it turns out it’s just the way it is. I did find this article where they say they wanted to make an album that would sound terrible in 10 years, but sorry guys it sounds terrible NOW!

I don’t know the first thing about recording music, so I don’t know whether it’s the production, engineering or something else that has made it sound this way. Whatever it is, the result is that the album sucks. Which is a real shame, because The Vaccines are a great energetic, melodic band with two great albums behind them. I’ve often gotten into a band after only discovering them at the third or fourth album and I’ve got to say that if this was my first experience of The Vaccines I would be in no hurry to listen to them again.

It sounds like there might be some good songs here too, I just can’t listen to it long enough to tell.

Score: 2 suns out 10 (1 for actually writing some decent songs and 1 for having the sheer balls to try something this stupid)


Here’s one they made earlier, which shows how good they CAN sound!

The best spot in the arena to watch the U2 U2ie tour is (Denver Night 1 report)…

Just a quick report from the road. U2’s U2ie tour rolled through Denver on June 6 and 7, and while already only 10 shows or so in, the performances are really running smooth and energetic, and by U2 standards fairly loose in the performances from the B-stage.

Having seen three U2ie shows so far from three different locations, I can say that for me at least being on the rail next to the B-stage right in front of where the band exits the “divider” is the best seat in the house if you don’t mind not seeing all of the big screen.

I’ve been to nearly 50 U2 shows over the years, and that spot is the closest proximity I’ve ever seen them from, close enough to have conversations with them during the B-stage sets.  You also see little things that you don’t see from the stands, like in Denver where Bono picked up a book copy of Dante’s Inferno and flipped it open and was reading it as he clambered up into the Divider. I think only the closest 20 people or so to that spot saw that sort of thing.

In terms of the musicianship, Larry (who in a shameless brag I’ll admit I got to meet briefly before the show, the last member of the band I’d never met) seems to be enjoying himself – well, at least by Larry standards – and Adam was his usual bemused, baronial self.

Edge seems to not be particularly enjoying himself and was extremely focused on his playing, and Bono seems looser and more spontaneous than usual.

The band is mixing in new or rarely played songs here and there in the set; from Denver the definite high-point to me was two songs in when they played a vibrant version of “Electric Co.” which I hadn’t heard live from them since the 80s.

Bono is also in excellent vocal form right now, even if he doesn’t seem 100% rehabilitated from the bike accident.  If you have any doubts about his vocals, see the video I “shot” for Every Breaking Wave below…

Gig Review: Ride – Glasgow Barrowland – May 22nd 2015


Ride All

It only took them 21 years, but the wait for Ride to return to the Glasgow Barrowland was worth it. Seen as one of the UK’s most influential bands from the Shoegaze scene, Ride were always more than just a shoegaze band, which stood them apart from their peers. Their sound encompassed different styles from psychedelia to garage rock and even pop.

Almost as soon as they split in 1996 fans have campaigned for a reunion and, inspired by the unlikely Stone Roses reunion, it finally happened in 2015. After a show in their home town of Oxford, then a short tour of the USA, the European leg of their tour kicked off in Glasgow at the iconic Barrowland.

Just like the Ride shows of the past it began in dramatic fashion, with the band not taking to the stage until long after the lights went down, the crowd getting more and more frenzied the whole time.

Mouse Trap from second album Going Blank Again was a surprise opener, followed immediately by Chelsea Girl from their debut EP. In fact the whole set, with the exception of one song, was taken from their early EPs and first two albums. Black Nite Crash from their final album Tarantula did feature, but there was nothing at all from Carnival of Light, perhaps not surprising when the band themselves dubbed it ‘Carnival of Shite’!

For a band who hadn’t toured for 21 years it was remarkable that they could play an almost two hour set with the same energy as they did in their heyday. Loz Colbert was an unstoppable force on drums, Steve Queralt on bass was the usual quiet man, but a driving force, and dual front men Andy Bell and Mark Gardener took turns at both creating a magical atmosphere and knocking the life out of their guitars.  No more did the guitars get a beating than during Seagull, the opening track from their debut album Nowhere. This was also the point where the famously chaotic Barrowland crowd lived up to its reputation. I’ve posted a clip of this song as an illustration of how difficult it can be to hold a camera bang in the middle of ‘The Barras’.

The only gripe for me was the lack of Nowhere, the bands most ‘shoegaze-y’ song, but they more than made up for it with a glorious Chrome Waves and an epic version of Drive Blind, which ended the main set.

The encore included early track Like a Daydream and ended with biggest hit Leave Them All Behind, another epic, which pretty much sums up the whole show.

I don’t know what the future holds for Ride, but hopefully it won’t be another 21 years before we see them again.

Set List:
Mouse Trap
Chelsea Girl
Polar Bear
Cool Your Boots
Black Nite Crash
Dreams Burn Down
Time of Her Time
Chrome Waves
Vapour Trail
Drive Blind

Like a Daydream
Leave Them All Behind

Full video of Dreams Burn Down, from debut album Nowhere:

Partial video of Seagull, a good insight into what it’s like in the middle of a Barrowland crowd!

First Nights On Earth – U2 World Tour Opening Nights on the U2ie “Innocence and Experience” tour in Vancouver, British Columbia


U2 take flight on the premiere nights of the “Innocence And Experience” tour in Vancouver on 2015-05-14 and 2015-05-15 and reinvent the arena rock show in the process.



This review is essentially just one extended spoiler of the new U2I&E  (or “U2ie”) tour from the first two shows on 2015-05-14 and 05-15 in Vancouver, British Columbia. If you want to be surprised at the show, read at your own risk.

This is fan’s review from what theoretically are the best (RED zone front row, first night) and worst (first section behind the band, second night) seats in the house.

 U2 “first nights” are like a first kiss – full of hope and expectation, but usually a little uncertain, hesitant and sloppy. The band really seemed on their game for these two shows though; it was clear that they were on their game.

 Yes, there was the glitch at the every end of the first show where The Edge fell off the stage, err, “downloaded himself into the audience without permission”, as Bono clarified at the second show, but other than a couple of slow transitions between set pieces, it was a powerful, energetic show that went off in mid-tour form.

But yes, because it’s the thing everyone was talking about, here’s the infamous opening night moment:


The months (heck, years) leading up to U2’s new U2ie tour have been difficult for U2. Several stop/starts during the recording process with multiple collaborators and producers were then compounded by the well-intentioned but clumsily executed album release debacle on iTunes. On the subsequent early promotional tour for Songs Of Innocence it appeared that the Grim Reaper had finally come to collect his dues on Bono’s charmed life, from the incident where a cargo door fell off a plane Bono was flying in and then of course Bono’s bicycle accident that required several months of physical therapy and that has left him unable to play guitar.

When combined with the atypically modest chart success of The Miracle (which the band has taken to renaming “Joey Ramone”) and the reworked piano/voice version of “Every Breaking Wave” U2 could have been forgiven for just sitting this round out from a tour standpoint. Given their tour history, they don’t have anything to prove to anyone at this point, and there’s no way that they could get bigger than the U2360 tour, whose stage was literally so big that it poked out of some of the stadiums that hosted the U2360 “claw”.

However, the band really believe in the songs on the new album, and one truism is that U2’s songs come alive in a concert setting in a way that transcends the album versions, so clearly there was going to be a tour up to U2’s expectations, but they kept the stage setup under more secrecy than usual.

The press hype leading up to the U2ie tour was more subdued than any tour in recent memory, and so it was hard to know what to expect from U2ie. The band seemed to be really downplaying the expectations for this tour to focus on the music and less on the extravangant stage show ala U2360.

So if you’re U2, what to do?

Just reinvent the arena concert experience, that’s what.

The secret weapon of U2ie is “The Divider” – a giant double-sided video wall that runs the entire arena from the main stage set at one end of the arena to the satellite B-stage. At first it just looks like any video wall, but then as you look closer you can see that there’s a catwalk-width corridor running the entire length, and then look even more closely and you can see that the walls are slightly see-through, have ladders on either end and trapdoors underneath for reasons that only become obvious later.

More than a gimmick, the Divider is an integral part of the show. During the show, there are times where it is used for “just” projected images, but there are other times where the images interact with the band members who periodically climb inside the Divider and play from the inside in what must seem like a cage. You can see them pretty clearly inside the Divider, who knows what they can see. More on all this below in the song-by-song discussion.

Much has been made of the sound mix at U2ie, and the hype is justified. The sound at U2 shows has been exceptional starting with ZooTV back in the early 90’s, but they’ve definitely gone one step closer to perfect arena sound with the U2ie setup.

Whether it’s because they run some of the speakers down the length of the main stage, or whether they are doing electronic sequencing and processing, the sound is extremely well balanced throughout the arena. The sound level and mix seemed the same to me from the front row in the RED zone to the stands behind the band.

The volume is never too high or too low and the equalization between the four main band performances (as well as the sweetening magic for the additional arena sound like the Lykke Li background vocals on The Troubles and the sequencer on Bad) is near perfection. I see a lot of shows by a lot of bands and I think that the U2ie setup is the new canonical standard for arena sound.

One last point – having a satellite B-stage is nothing new, but bands typically don’t make good use of the space between. Even U2’s previous runway “heart” stages weren’t really used to full effect other than occasional Bono-forays out to sing from the tip, or the nutty U2360 performances of “I Know I’ll Go Crazy”. Here there were set pieces where the band was strung out evenly spaced down the runway stage, and pieces where band members would prowl the runway while another member was inside the Divider. This was used to best effect on Cedarwood Road and Until The End Of The World (see more below).

Overall impressions:

Overall the band was in superb, mid-tour form. Bono’s voice sounded as good as ever, and he still goes for it to the end of his range as much as ever. I didn’t notice any lingering effects from his prolonged rehab after the bicycle accident, and if he didn’t run around the stage like a maniac like at times on even the U2360 that can be forgiven at this stage of their career.

Edge, Adam and Larry were also in mid-tour form, with Edge as usual being a wizard in the sounds being coaxed out of his kit, and creating an orchestra’s worth of volume as always. Adam was his usual comfortable and bemused self as he prowled his end of the stage and Larry was workmanlike and intense as always, possibly heightened by the loss of his 92-year old father earlier in the week.

All four members appeared to enjoy best playing the new songs from SOI with nine of the twelve tracks (if you include “Invisible”) showing up over the two nights (seven of which were played both nights and which were the lynchpins of the show).

One note: early on U2 had intimated that on this tour where they’re typically playing multiple nights at the same venues that the second nights would have radically different setlists than the first nights. Rumor is that they had practiced sixty songs for the approximately twenty-five that they pick nightly. And while to be fair the six songs they only played on night two is more than they typically mix in from show to show; still don’t expect to see a radically different show on nights 2 and beyond.

The visuals they have mapped to some of the songs are ones that they’ll want to use every show and the way that some of the songs are specifically sequenced for effect tells me that the shuffling of songs will primarily come at three points – at the start before the visuals kick in, at the B-stage mid-set, and at the end of the show and encore. These are the times where the band is “naked” without the Divider visuals and so this gives them a bit more flexibility.

For the fans that were expecting the “first night” shows to be the main experience and the “second night” shows to have a deeper-cut playlist, I’m not sure that it will play out that way. I think the mix of songs will be consistent at multi-night venues with typically a surprise or two each night.

Song wise, with them believing so much in the SOI songs, something has to go in the setlist and so several past favorites have been retired, at least as songs that get played every night: no New Year’s Day, In God’s Country, All I Want Is You, The Fly, no One on first night (more below on this below), no Elevation or Walk On, and nothing from Pop or No Line On The Horizon.

On the down side it feels like something is missing to not have NYD, Elevation, Walk On or One; on the other hand I admire that the band has so much faith in the new songs. If previous U2 tours are any indication, I’d expect that over the course of the tour they’ll cull a couple of the SOI songs as they discover which ones work best in the U2ie context.

One other point – on both nights Bono kept the political and humanitarian speechifying to a minimum. I never minded that and I hope that he’s not cutting back on his ideals because of pressure from the folks who give him so much trouble about his “boring preachy part”.

Here’s a quick song-by-song impression (forgive the spoilers):



Interesting pre-show warmup music which seemed to be same both nights, pretty much post-punk and new-wave songs that were all (or pretty much all) from 1980. Clearly they were trying to lock in a groove from when they were first starting out, even if there were some artists that were probably favorites of theirs at the time (Patty Smith, The Clash, Simple Minds) and some that would have been at best guilty pleasures (A Flock Of Seagulls, Plastic Bertrand (!)).

There were several false alarms where the crowd thought that the show was eminent, but be listening for the Ramones’ “Baby I Love You” and “Beat On The Brat” which the band lists on their set-list call sheet as part of the set (see at bottom of this post)

“Beat On The Brat” is the cue that the show is starting, with what sounds like a bit of sweetening from Edge’s guitar. From behind the stage you could see the band enter the arena and walk under the stage during “Beat On The Brat” and then take the stage.

1) The Miracle (Joey Ramone)

Both night’s began with rousing renditions of Joey Ramone (as the band calls the song on the setlist) that get the night off to a festive start from the main stage that the band calls the “Square Stage”. For the first four songs they don’t use visuals from the Divider, the only visual is the single lightbulb spotlight about the stage and for the folks lucky enough to be in the front of the GA and RED sections it’s like being transported back to 1980 and seeing them in a club. The audience clearly knows the song by heart already and was in full throat for the “Wo-o-o-o” choruses. Not my favorite song from the album but a perfect beginning to the show, announcing that U2 are back and ready to go.

2) Out Of Control

Night 1 went straight into “Out Of Control” with a snipped of “Do You Remember Rock and Roll” prefaced with the same “…this is our first single” patter they’ve used on previous tours. I’m always surprised by how much the audience seems to know this song.

3) Vertigo

Out Of Control went straight into Vertigo with no over-the-top visuals, just the band playing straight-ahead.

4) I Will Follow

Back to 1980 with I Will Follow which had the whole stadium bouncing. First high point of the night.


On Night 2 they skipped Out Of Control and went straight from Joey Ramone to Vertigo, but then added in a nice version of California (There Is No End) for song 3 preceding I Will Follow. As much as I like Out Of Control, I think that the night two order worked better.

5) Iris (Hold Me Close)

After the first bang-bang four songs, Bono slows down the tempo and has a nice heartfelt interlude about his mother Iris, mentioning something along the lines about not wanting to live in the past but needing to remember it. This is was the first time that they started using the catwalk stage and the first time they started using the Divider for more than band performance shots, with what appeared to be home-video footage of Bono’s mother and a very young Bono. Bono’s vocals were heart-felt and vulnerable and you could tell that no matter what the haters think the new SOI material really does matter to him.  Listen for the snippet from “Mofo” during Iris, a song that couldn’t be more different musically but does link lyrically.

6) Cedarwood Road

Here’s where U2ie starts to get really interesting. At the conclusion of Iris, a ladder descends from the Divider from the square stage and Bono invites the crowd to take a walk with him along the Cedarwood Road of his youth as he climbs the ladder and goes inside the Divider as the crowd anticipation builds.

As the song begins you don’t see Bono making his way down to the B-side of the Divider but then as the video wall lights up you see an animated side-scrolling movie evoking the Cedarwood Road of their youth as they remember it. As Bono slowly walks down the inside of the Divider, the bright animation scrolls past and because you can see him inside it appears that he’s walking down the road, down to the graffiti of the time and the blossoms falling off the trees. It’s a very simple but powerful effect. It’s also the first time in the show where you see band members simultaneously on the stage beneath the Divider and in it, with Edge on the main stage immediately below Bono while Bono is inside the Divider. It’s as if Edge is providing a musical narration of the road while Bono walks down it.

7) Song For Someone

As Cedarwood Road ends the video wall animation moves to the inside of a teenager’s bedroom with a young Bono (with the animation of the teenage Bono purportedly played by his real-life son) sitting in his bedroom beneath Kraftwerk and Clash posters.

As the intro starts Bono talks a bit about songwriting as a youth and trying to find the way to describe first experiences like first love, first kiss, etc., and then gave a shout-out to his wife Ali. This was really a surprisingly poignant way to set up the song and fit the mood, the lyrics, the vocals and the music perfectly. Very impressive, and the first time that Bono is singing by himself from the “round stage” at the far end of the arena from the rest of the band who stay on the square stage, evoking both physical distance and the distance of memory.

8) Sunday Bloody Sunday (acoustic)

After Song For Someone the rest of the band all moved as a group down the runway stage and spread themselves out equally across the length of the arena, Larry carrying a lap-snare and Edge his acoustic. They they laid out a surprisingly elegiac, funereal acoustic version of Sunday Bloody Sunday, played straightforward and almost hymn-like. From the floor you can’t really tell this but they light show paints an Irish flag on the runway.

DSC00150 - SBS

At the end, the video screen showed the victims as if to bring the crowd back to the moment of the attack to appreciate why this had such an effect on the nascent U2, along with a Bono quick patter celebrating Ireland’s current relative peace, saying that “because no-one won, we all won”.

9) Raised By Wolves

SBS ends with a montage of sounds, news overdubs, sirens and crashes and with Larry doing slow snare hits as if intoning funeral bells, and then they go straight into a thundering, pounding version of Raised By Wolves with what sounded like a Psalm 23 snippet. A highlight of the album and a powerful moment in the show.

10) Until The End Of The World

This was my favorite example of how they combine the visual wall with band members inside it. Edge is inside the Divider playing the classic riffs of UTEOTW with Bono out on the B-stage in full Mephistopheles mode, and as the temptation lyrics unfold Bono is projected onto the video wall in full size “Attack of the 50-foot Bono” mode and the stage crew projects Bono is if he is playing with life-size Edge almost as a prop in his hand, poking, teasing and waving at him in a playful yet menacing way.

I’ve always thought the bullfight-style interaction between Edge/Bono was a highlight of previous tours; yet there is something that’s even more powerful about God-size Bono playing with Edge here that is even more evocative of the lyrics.

The direct interaction between Bono and Edge gives way as Bono waves his hands at the “waves of regret” portion and the remainder of the song puts Technicolor animation over the wall as Edge wails away at the guitar like a caged animal, a man possessed. The crescendo builds up to the point where the single lightbulb from the main stage shows up on the video wall and shatters, denoting loss of innocence.

I don’t if it’s because Edge is essentially trapped in a cage inside the Divider or whether he’s just not distracted by the crowd, but when he’s inside the Divider he was playing some of the most snarling, vicious guitar that I’ve ever heard from him.

Overall, an unforgettable setpiece that really puts the new setup to best effect, and brings the first set to a rapturous and breathless end, and leaves the crowd needing a respite.

Sidenote 1: At the end during the “la-la-la-la’s” the band drops buckets of pages from the rafters ala earlier tours, only this time the pages (at least the page I grabbed) were bible pages; I got Psalm 43. Between this and the giant Bono, I know that my Bono-hating friends would just be cringing and rolling their eyes. There comes a point where you either buy Bono’s schtick or you don’t. To a true believer it’s close to the Holy Spirit moving on a crowd; if you’re a skeptic every terrible thing you’ve ever said about U2 has just been evoked.   Either way, you have to admire a band that wears its heart and soul on its sleeve and brings out passion, because isn’t the evocation of emotion the central point of music in the first place?


Sidenote 2: For night 2, I was basically edge-on (no pun intended) to see the catwalk inside the Divider but couldn’t see the main screen. This was the first time that I really saw a limitation in not being able to see the main Divider. While they have set up a small screen (roughly the size of one of the ones used on U2360) they use it mostly for b&w band shots and some of the setpieces. During UTEOTW because they only had the Bono performance view, so while most of the audience was seeing Giant Bono holding Edge in his hand all you could see from the edge of the wall was him waving his hands like a hula dancer and poking his hands into space for no apparent reason. This was one of the few times where the show was significantly degraded by being behind the band.


The “intermission” runs about 4-5 minutes and consists of a montage of late 1970’s talk-show interviews and performances with punk and post-punk performers and bands. While I loved seeing the images and footage, this section didn’t really come off as strong as I think the band had hoped, and the crowd seemed disinterested on both nights. I’d expect that this section will be revamped along the way.


11) Invisible

Somehow the band all get inside the Divider undetected and the second set begins with the video wall a solid lemon yellow as Invisible begins to play. The conceit here is that in rhythm with the music and performance tiny portions of the yellow screen go clear so that you can see little bits and pieces of the band as they play, eventually leading up to the end where the screen is completely clear and you see the band through the walls of the screen for the end of the song. A simple but entertaining idea that seems sort of like something that Kraftwerk would have done if they’d had the technology.

12) Even Better Than The Real Thing

Invisible segues into a rollicking, pounding version of EBTTRT with bright visuals on the screen and the band making their way out of the Divider and down to the round stage. They were really cooking towards the rousing end of the song.

13) Mysterious Ways

Now ensconced on the round stage and the runway on that end of the arena, it was time for a faithful if predictable version of Mysterious Ways that really sounded terrific (with a snipped of “Burning Down The House” thrown in).

Night 2 had a nice surprise where a male audience member was brought up to sing with Bono. I read in a local Vancouver newspaper that the man was a video filmmaker making a movie about confronting fear and one of his bucket-list items was to sing with U2. Whether that was him or not, there was one of those classic U2 moments on night 2 where the man and Bono were on the runway and the man spontaneously picked up Bono almost like a baby and carried him back to the round stage. Bono didn’t break and kept singing throughout in a moment that had the sold-out crowd laughing.

IMG_0987 - Mysterious

14/15) Night 1: Desire/The Sweetest Thing; Night 2: Angel Of Harlem/When Love Comes To Town

This looks to be the part of the show where U2 will shake up the setlist most on this tour. Visually the cameras are just doing performance shots of the band so they’ll be able to mix in most anything they feel like playing.

On Night 1 it was a straightforward version of Desire followed by a nice version of The Sweetest Thing with Bono on piano (he may not be able to play guitar anymore but apparently he can still play piano). Sweetest Thing sent a real murmur through the crowd because it’s rarely played; I believe it’s the first time that it had been played in concert since midway on the Elevation tour.

On Night 1, BB King had passed that day but I don’t remember any mention of it from the band. However, on Night 2 Bono did pay a quick elegy to Mr. King and then they launched into a blistering version of When Love Comes To Town that came off so well that it’s hard to believe that they hadn’t played it in concert since 1993.

Anyone who’s gone to a concert in the last few years knows that one of the most annoying trends in concerts is the ubiquitous presence of people holding up their cell-phones to catch snapshots and videos. (Confession: I do the same thing from time to time, as in some of the videos here in this blog). Hypocrisy, thy name is “self”.

For the second song on both nights in this slot, U2 decided that rather than curtail the cellphones they’d take advantage. On both nights they pulled an attractive young woman from the audience (some things never change at a U2 concert) and had her be a videographer using her cell phone, with the video outputs from the cellphones tied directly to the house video so that while they had the phone in video mode what they were seeing was being projected to the entire house. It’s a neat idea of reaching out to the crowd, but the bandwidth delay of the video capture to the house video meant that the video was out of sync with the music. I wouldn’t mind if they lost that part.

Here’s Sweetest Thing from Day 1 and When Love Comes To Town from Day 2:

16) Every Breaking Wave

At this point, Larry and Adam walk back down the runway to the square stage while Bono and Edge stay at the round stage with Edge at piano, and then they launch into the passionate and heartbreaking acoustic version of Every Breaking Wave that they’ve been playing since last fall during the SOI promotional TV performances.

This to me is the best thing on SOI and hearing Bono’s voice soar in person with the strength and power of his vocals reminds you that no matter what you think of Bono he’s one of the best rock vocalists ever. The crowd was singing along louder to this song than any other song of the night as a giant (if mostly off-key!) chorus backing him up. Within seconds of the piano starting on both nights, the arena was awash in cell-phone flashlights, the Century 21 version of lighters aloft. A real high point both nights.

IMG_1001 - Every Breaking

17) Bullet The Blue Sky

Next up was the blistering, cacophonous and biting return of Bullet The Blue Sky to the setlist. The band played with the intensity of the ZooTV tour here while the “fighter planes” were being replaced here with the “private planes” Bono referenced, substituting bankers and the ultra-rich for the American militarism and colonialism that Bono used to decry.

The spoken word portion of Bullet now ties to a story Bono tells of landing in a private plane in Davos Switzerland as part of an economic conference and seeing a 19-year old boy reminding him of himself at that age, and seeing himself through the eyes of that boy telling that he has too much money.

Bono then launched on both nights into an extended patter like a Penecostal preacher imploring unity and togetherness. Edge seemed delighted to have Bullet back in the setlist, and he gave the solo a real working over while Bono next to him assumed the position of airplane, arms outstretched like airplane wings.

To the Bono-haters, I’ll only say that I’ll allow that many of Bono’s perceived flaws and excesses are true but only if you’ll admit that at least most of the positive things people say about him as a performer and person are also true.

You know who you are.

18) Pride (with Hands That Built America intro)

The emotional wave in the crowd from Bullet was extended in the next piece as Bono sang an extended snippet of Hands That Built America along with a callback to the recent racial violence in Ferguson, MO with a “Hands Up Don’t Shoot” reference before starting a monologue about America as an idea more than a physical place. This section got polite applause from the Canadian audience but will probably resonate more later in on the US legs of the tour.

“Hands” segued into a workmanlike and serviceable version of Pride on both nights.

19) The Troubles / Beautiful Day

Here’s another place where the set differed from Day 1 to Day 2. On Day 1 at the end of Pride the stagehands set up a cocktail kit drum set for Larry at the front of stage left (audience right) complete with tilted bass drum, and with Bono still across the arena at the round stage Larry started into The Troubles on the drums with an offstage keyboard. It was a slow, patient version of The Troubles that I thought was quite powerful with interesting full-screen black and white headshots of Lykke Li while Bono sang stationary at the standup mike.

The tables had turned and now it was Bono who was small and fragile with Li the towering presence. I thought it worked really well especially at the “God knows it’s not easy…” bridge but they took it out of the show for the second show. Hopefully they’ll keep it in the show and let it breathe because it could turn out to be a real grower over the life of the tour, especially with the Edge solo at the end that is vaguely reminiscent of the Love Is Blindness solo.

In its place on Day 2, substituted a crowd-pleasing version of Beautiful Day (which shows up later on Day 1).

20) With Or Without You

Both days ended the second set with a slightly slowed-down but still-intense version of With Or Without You as mirrorballs descended from the Divider. The Day 2 version was especially powerful at the end and my attention got drawn again to Larry’s drumming; steady, powerful, and metronomic but evocative at the same time. It’s interesting to hear what a great drummer can do with a rocksteady 4/4 beat.


21) City Of Blinding Lights / Miracle Drug

The encore begins with scenes of Earth as seen by the International Space Station over a one-minute passage from astrophysicist Stephen Hawking including the phrases “…we are one” which led most of the crowd to think it was the intro to “One”, as the vertical/horizontal fluorescent-tube lightbars, which are the iconic press images of U2ie, descended into place.

Surprisingly, though next up it wasn’t “One” – in fact on Day 1 One wasn’t played at all which was the first time at an official full-length show they’d skipped One since January 1990.

Instead on Day 1 it was a ringing version of City Of Blinding Lights where the crowd joined in as always on the “Oh…you…look…so…beautiful…tonight” as the house lights swirled.

Bono pulled up a young boy out of the audience and placed him on the runway next to one of the vertical lightbars and then seemingly forgot about him for quite some time. The boy was roughly 5 years older than the boy(s) who got pulled out of the crowd for COBL on U2360, which might me a coincidence or deliberate.

On Day 2 it was a real surprise as they started the encore with a note-perfect performance of Miracle Drug along with a short Bono-speech on how we hope to see the scourge of HIV/AIDS eliminated in our lifetime. This was the first time that Miracle Drug had been played since the Vertigo tour and it sounded great. During the extended guitar break Bono worked his way down the runway down the row of lightbars in what was a very powerful vocal performance.

Here’s Day 1 City Of Blinding Lights and Day 2 Miracle Drug:

22) Beautiful Day / Bad

On Day1, COBL was followed up with a rousing version of Beautiful Day complete with an “I Remember You” snippet with Bono starting at the square stage and then working his way down the runway to the round stage.

On Day 2, with Bono already at the round stage the familiar sequencer strains of “Bad” started up at this point and a lot of the older fans lost it, as “Bad” has a special place in the hearts of long-time fans. I admit I’m one of them; my perfect U2 concert would consist of a two-hour version of Bad.   Here Bono, alone on the round stage under a single spotlight stood across the arena facing the band and it was a fantastic vocal performance from him, including a quick callout to Moment of Surrender that I’d never connected until that point.IMG_1015 - Bad

It was a typically outstanding vocal performance, and one of the few times where being right behind the band and able to look down the runway was the best seat in the house, with Bad serving as a journey to Heaven down the lighted runway.

I love the fact that they only play “Bad” about 10% of the time in concert, so it’s always a great surprise when it shows up.

23) Mother And Child Reunion / Where The Streets Have No Name

Probably the biggest surprise on both nights was the extended acoustic snippet of Paul Simon’s Mother And Child Reunion which served as the intro to Where The Streets Have No Name. Streets sounded as good as ever and brought the crowd to a rapturous climax. It’s no surprise that this song has endured in the setlist, it’s one of the most dependable crowd-pleasers from any rock band in rock history and just looking at the sea of raised hands is as close to a church experience that can be had in a secular setting. Both nights included a snippet of California (There Is No End…)

24) I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For / One

After the crowd was happily exhausted after pogoing on Streets, for the final song they segued surprisingly into chart hits for their final song. On Day 1 it was the now-infamous version of Still Haven’t Found where Edge fell off stage and on Day 2 it was the return of One. One sounded exactly the same as always even though Bono no longer was using his beloved Gretsch Green Falcon guitar.

. 🙂

And as the band exited the arena to the final strains the house lights came up and the show was over. Until the next time.

I’ve seen U2 now close to 50 times total over their career. It’s too soon to think right now where the U2ie shows rank in their overall portfolio, but it’s amazing to see a band 35 years into their career that are still at the height of their careers and still pushing themselves lyrically, musically, visually and in performance. As long as the crowd can tell that it’s not BS to the band, they’ll continue to be worth supporting and I at least for one… will follow.


Just a couple of quick notes for U2ie concert-goers…

GA Section

Starting with Elevation, many of the youngest and most ardent (often not the same) U2 fans have realized that the GA tickets are the way to go. Not only are they cheaper but they bring you closer to the band, even if at the expense of not seeing the full visual experience. The true-blood fans are willing to trade immediacy for the visuals.

One thing I noticed this show was that the GA queue seemed to swell earlier in the day than usual, or so it seemed to me. It seems like people have thought based on the last few tours that you have to queue up early to get the best places on the floor.

For U2ie, I think this is less important than on the previous tours, where there was a push to either get inside the “Heart” or to be on the outside first row of the catwalk. The band spend enough time on the runway, inside the Divider and on the round stage that unless you’re looking to get Bono-sweat on you pretty much anywhere in the GA section is going to be a good choice.

In other words, the queue during the day seems to be longer, and earlier in arriving, but less important in the long run than on previous tours.

RED Section

I was in the RED section for Day 1 (first time in the RED zone for me), and my advice to concert-goers is to get RED tickets because you believe in ONE and RED, and not because you’re looking for a “Golden-Circle” experience. The area on the floor for the RED tickets is outside of the GA area extending down to the stage on the far ends, and I didn’t notice the benefits that I’d heard of previously in terms of concessions and merchandise.

Since there are only 100 seats in each of the North and South zones, there is one advantage of having a little more space to stretch out and dance if you’re not obsessed with getting as close to the action as possible.

In terms of one of the carrots that they throw out for RED Zone (the backstage tour) what they do is draw raffle-style tickets out of a bucket where two are labeled “backstage tour”. So, only two out of two-hundred people get the backstage tour, there’s no meet-and-greet and your plus-one doesn’t get to come. Plus you lose your spot in line to get your place on the floor.

I believe in RED as a concept and a product, but I can’t really endorse the extra cost of the ticket other than as a donation to RED, which is a worthy cause.

“North Side” and “South Side”

For both the GA and RED Zone, you get confined to either one side of the Divider or the other. I suppose that it will be different for every arena but at Rogers Arena in Vancouver RED Zone 1 and “North Side” were on Adam’s side, while RED Zone 2 and “South Side” were Edge side.

If you’re particularly interested in being on either Edge’s side or Adams’s side, I’d suggest you sort that out before entering the arena, because they have separate entry lines for north/south side, and it’s hard once you’re in the arena to move between the sides without a bit of ingenuity.

End Zone

As I mentioned above, given that so much of the visuals are driven by the Divider even though they make the effort to have a smaller screen for the folks directly behind the band, you’re definitely not getting the full experience of people down the sides (or even near the round stage). I’d suggest paying a little more and avoiding the spot directly behind the band.

IMG_0991 - overhead

The Merch

People always want to know about the Merch. This time with no opening act all of the merch is U2-related, but it’s pretty subdued this time around (see pic below). There are the usual assortment of T-shirts (running approx. 40-45 $), hats, tote bags and programs, but the big item this go-around seemed to be the hoodies, which came in two styles and ran 90$. I didn’t see some of the other items this time like skull caps and jackets, but the quality seemed pretty good (by concert-gear standards).



Day 1 set list courtesy of

Day 2 set list courtesy of

Screen Shot 2015-05-16 at 3.05.14 PM

Gig Review: Of Monsters And Men – Washington DC – 2015-05-05

The Icelandic Indie folk/acoustic darlings drop a batch of new songs from the upcoming “Beneath The Skin” along with crowd favorites from “My Head Is An Animal” on the faithful in Washington DC.

Certain things in music are generally true, including the assertion that any English-speaking Icelandic band is going to be quirky, individualistic and worth a listen.

That truism has been valid at least as far back as the Sugarcubes/Bjork, continuing through bands like Seabear and Quarashi and of course Sigur Ros. Of Monsters And Men carried through on that proud tradition on 2015-05-05 in their soldout show in Washington DC at Echostage, where they previewed several tracks from their upcoming (June 2015) new album “Beneath The Skin” along with popular favorites.

Of Monsters And Men’s debut album “My Head Is An Animal” was an unlikely hit in 2012 in American alternative circles with several infectious hit singles and clever animated videos including “Little Talks”, “Dirty Paws”, “King and Lionheart” and “Mountain Sound”. OMAM hit US shores at the crest of the wave of acoustic/folk bands that followed in the wake of the Mumford & Sons breakthrough, and were often lumped in with both European and US bands that on the surface carry a similar sensibility such as the Noah & The Whale, The Head And The Heart, The Lumineers, The Avett Brothers, etc.

I thought that “My Head Is An Animal” stood out from the rest of the pack as one of the best albums of 2012, combining some of the best of the Arcade Fire, The Head And The Heart and The Wind And the Wave. The lyrics were interestingly impenetrable, and I really liked the timbre of singer and guitarist/drummer Nanna Bryndis Hilmarsdottir’s voice. Hilmarsdottir’s voice has just a trace of Bjork in her slightly-accented English, and her voice melds nicely with other singer/guitarist Ragnar Porhallsson.

I’m still not sure that I understand all of the metaphors in their lyrics (at least I’m assuming they’re metaphors), but the big-hearted singalong style in their hypermelodic folkish choruses make you feel that their songs have always existed and the melodies are very pleasant and accessible, albeit with a slightly dark twinge. They have released lyric videos for several songs off of MHIAA but which don’t help me a bit to understand the songs, and I’m OK with that.

OMAM have kept a low profile since the extended touring that accompanied My Head Is An Animal but have just started touring in North America in support of the upcoming “Beneath The Skin”, and they played several brand new songs at Echostage, including the two strong new songs that have already been released, “Crystals” and “I Of The Storm”, leading off the show with two brand new songs.

“I Of The Storm” might be the more representative example of the new songs, which in general seemed not as immediately accessible as the singles from MHIAA but are probably growers on extended listens. The choruses seemed smaller and overall their sound has grown and evolved, broadening and deepening the heavily percussive and rhythmic elements with heavy bass drums and martial snares. Along with the percussive elements, they kept enough fragile keyboards along with some trancelike atmospherics from the hollow-body guitars and even an occasional trombone to broaden the sound and keep it from getting too heavy. As a comparison point, the song off of the first album that ties closest to the new songs might be “Your Bones”.

None of the songs had the mass-vocal bounce of “Mountain Sound” or “Little Talks” but they probably realize that they had mined that vein pretty fully on the debut album and their earlier “Into The Woods” EP from 2011. There was also the natural tendency of a young band to be a bit more tentative on brand new songs as opposed to the songs on the debut album that they’ve been playing in concert since 2011 (if you include the Into The Woods).

There is a fine line between fully realizing a signature sound, and reaching a musical dead-end. The evolution of the new OMAM sound is not nearly as pronounced as on the new Mumford & Sons album but it is a noticeable difference from MHIAA and bodes well for the band’s future as the winds of the music industry change. They appear to have avoided painting themselves into the same corner that some of their “sibling” bands appear to have done.

In concert, while OMAM play as an ensemble, Hilmarsdottir really draws your eyes as the center of attention, occasionally playing a bass drum on the side and being the most animated of the performers. She is the motor that drives the band live and gives it a distinctive character.

As with any concert where the band emphasizes brand-new songs, the audience saved the majority of their enthusiasm for their favorites from the album they knew, and this show was no exception.“Slow And Steady” was the first song from MHIAA and got a big crowd reaction, and the show reached an early peak with an enthusiastic rendition of “Mountain Sound”.

Predictably though it was “Dirty Paws” and especially “Little Talks” during the encore that blew the roof off the Echostage as the pent-up enthusiasm of the crowd was released. It did seem to me that the band seemed slightly uncomfortable playing their intimate songs to a 2,000+ person ecstatic, bouncing crowd and I do think that their future is going to be playing more acoustic and intimate shows; in either case though I think that this is a band that’s in it for the long haul.

Overall, a very nice performance by an up and coming young band. I’m looking forward to hearing the new album and hearing how it compared to what I heard last night. Definitely worth seeing if they come to your town.

“Beneath the Skin” is released world-wide on 2015-06-09 while “Crystals” and “I Of The Storm” are already available on iTunes and on streaming services like Spotify.

To get a general feel for their sound in concert, here’s their set from Bonaroo 2013:


Album Review: Thomas Kercheval – We Were Here

If you’re a fan of Scottish rock band Big Country, you’ll love this album. Even if you’re not and you just enjoy quality rock music, you’ll still love it. Tom is a huge Big Country fan (as some reading this will know) and this is obvious in the album’s overall sound. He even played live with Big Country once, but he doesn’t like to talk about it. The album is self produced but this is no lo-fi bedroom portastudio effort; it’s highly professional sounding, but without being overly polished, which is a bigger crime in my book. What makes it more remarkable is that Tom plays all the instruments (according to the CD booklet) with the exception of some additional vocals, and the wind which is ‘courtesy of nature’. As a Big Country fan myself I can hear influences from the whole of the band’s career, from their first album right through to their later work and even demos and B-sides, but without being able to actually pinpoint particular songs. Well maybe just the once with the One Great Thing-like ending on The Ones Who Love You. There is even a track – Quasimodo – that is distinctly Skids sounding (you probably know this already but in case you don’t, the Skids were Big Country founder Stuart Adamson’s previous band.) There are a number of stand-out tracks, the best being Lonely Rider. It has a whole album’s worth of guitar parts crammed into one song, but every one fits perfectly and it never sounds cluttered. And if the guitars are not enough there’s even some keyboard bagpipes. Tom is a multi-instrumentalist, but even his talent doesn’t extend to the bagpipes, or maybe he just doesn’t own a real set, or doesn’t want to drive out all of his neighbours. Flicker is another of the stand-outs and is the most radio friendly song from the collection. It’s a song about love saving you from a destructive, or at least an unfulfilled life. Lyrically the album inhabits much of the Big Country territory, with songs about love, family and war. All except Window Unit, which appears to be a song about air conditioning, but it’s none the worse for it! This song actually contains my favourite lyric – “And you could never see how the weight of world kept pulling on me, and you’ll never understand all the strength you can find in a trembling hand” – poetic.

There are some much heavier moments to be found, particularly Melt Away with its menacing bass-line and lyrics. Then there’s the acoustic lull which gives way to an almighty scream that sounds like he’s channelling some Norwegian rage, followed by a top notch classic rock guitar solo. The album ends on a much lighter note with Papoose; Tom shows his versatility again with a bit of banjo and one of the best vocal performances. It’s hard to find fault with this album at all but if I’m being overly critical I don’t like some of the vocal effects, but strangely they work fantastically well on the female vocals on Flicker. I know we’re only in April so there’s much new music to come this year, but I’m already certain this album will make my end of year top 10.

Score: 9 suns out of 10 dc7ejqKc9

You can preview “We Were Here” on both Spotify and Reverbnation, at

The CD is also available at both CDBaby and Bandcamp at:



Gig Review: The Waterboys – Alexandria, VA – 2015-04-21

Mike Scott and his raggle-taggle gypsies burn the place down on the Modern Blues tour

Fresh off of a performance on the David Letterman show the night before (see link at bottom) Mike Scott and the current incarnation of The Waterboys played a blistering set on 2015.04.21 at the Birchmere in Alexandria, VA.

After an engaging opening set by Woodstock New York’s Connor Kennedy, Scott and his merry gang took the stage with Scott in Western garb and black hat, high-energy and ready for a storming evening of folk-inflected Celtic-flavored rock.


The set focused on songs from their outstanding new “Modern Blues” album with some new arrangements of classic Waterboys cuts thrown in for good measure.  It’s always a positive sign when a band that’s toured for more than three decades (!) at this point is so confident and happy with the recent material that the show emphasizes the newest songs. That the material was so well-received by a crowd ready to hear the classic hits is a testament to the Modern Blues song-cycle’s strength.

Of course, since the Waterboys collective frequently rotates in new members under the Waterboys banner it stands to reason that the band is always reinventing itself.  In addition to Head Waterboy Scott and founding-member electric fiddle whiz Steve Wickham, the current lineup boasts an amazingly skilled iineup of musicians including long-time drummer Ralph Salmins, fluid guitarist Zach Ernst (who appears younger than the debut Waterboys album), Muscle Shoals bass player David Hood and the indomitable, indescribable Brother Paul from Memphis on keyboards.

Each incarnation of the Waterboys has a distinct group personality, and the current version is no different. Taking their cue from Modern Blues, this is a straight-ahead, driving rock show propelled by Salmins, Scott and Ernst with Wickham and Brother Paul then pulling and tugging on the melodies and rhythms to create the distinct musical colors and shapes of Waterboys songs.

There were fewer long improvisational passages among the band members than I’ve seen at some Waterboys shows, but the passion, soul, spirit and infectious energy of the best of Waterboys shows was still in full effect.  Scott in particular played with renewed energy and vitality belying thirty years of touring, seated only when playing the keyboards and spending most of the show moving and dancing as he played.  It’s clear that he is both justly proud of the new material and believes in it, and he really is able to sell it to the crowd.  This version of the Waterboys plays with the skill and practice of a mature band but with the passion and energy of a young band.

They had played some of the Modern Blues songs like “Still A Freak” and “I Can See Elvis” in their fall 2013 North American tour, including locally in Washington DC at the 930 club, but at that show the songs were still like new shoes that hadn’t been broken in yet, and even though there were some personnel changes from that show, it’s clear that these songs have now been worn in and are being played with a confidence gainsaying the newness of the songs and newness of this combo as a playing unit.

While I was disappointed not to hear “The Girl Who Slept For Scotland” from the new album, they did play most of the songs from Modern Blues and also mixed in some of the crowd-pleasing classics.  “Still A Freak”, “November Tale” and “Long Strange Road” were particularly sharp.

Here was “Still A Freak”:

All of the older songs sounded fantastic and as fresh now as when newly-minted.  “Girl Called Johnny” galloped with Scott at the keyboards and Wickham providing the accents and they stone-cold nailed the audience favorite “Whole Of The Moon”. “Fisherman’s Blues” was a rousing sing-along encore and the old classic “Three Day Man” was a pleasant surprise.

Here was “Fisherman’s Blues”:

For me the highlights of the heritage material were the driving, pulsing version of the Fisherman’s Blues classic “We Will Not Be Lovers” and a spellbinding, showstopping version of “Don’t Bang The Drum” with just Scott and Wickham, both below:

Steve Wickham continues to provide the spice that makes the Waterboys such an interesting meal. Wickham plays with a mesmerizing lyricism and flow that provides color and character to each song. Although I’ve seen Scott play without Wickham, together they are magic; watching them up close they communicate with just a glance as they shift rhythms, speed and volumes. They play with the synergy that only comes with a lifetime of playing together.

You can’t discuss this incarnation of the Waterboys without focusing on the whirling dervish of a keyboard player that is Brother Paul. Brother Paul is a marvel to watch, a kinetic bundle of energy just short of exploding at all times, whipping his hair around and beaming the entire time. He plays in an extremely animated and thoroughly enjoyable style, throwing his hands at the keyboards like a wizard casting spells on the keys. There were a couple of times where after a particular flourish, Brother Paul would look over to Scott like a child caught in the cookie jar asking tacit forgiveness. Brother Paul’s ageless enthusiasm is a real joy to behold, and worth the price of admission alone.

One practical tip: with all apologies to Ernst and Hood who while virtuoso musicians keep a low profile onstage, try to work your way over to audience-left (stage-right) which is the area that Wickham and Brother Paul inhabit. They’re worth seeing up close.


Scott can be a mercurial performer, and you know you’re at a classic Waterboys show when at some point Scott has to berate the crowd for misbehaving and you’re treated to an “aw, snap” moment. In this case, during a particularly quiet passage in “Song Of The Wandering Aengus (from the 2011 tribute album to W.B. Yeats poetry called “An Appointment With Mr. Yeats”) the rather noisy crowd was clearly bothering Scott who stopped the song about 30 seconds in and sternly addressed the throng:

“Perhaps we should play more quietly so that you can hear each other talk more clearly?”.

The crowd went stone silent for 15 seconds or so and Scott was content to let the silence linger. Then he calmly restarted the song and within a few seconds the crowd was back in the swing. Classic.

In short, it’s great to see Mike Scott and The Waterboys at the top of their game 31 years after they first toured the US. If you have the opportunity to see them play in your town, by all means treat yourself to one of the finest rock bands extant.  If they’re not coming to your town, you need to move to a better town. Life’s too short not to fill it with great live music from a masterful group.

Setlist from the show as best I remember:


Destinies Entwined

Still A Freak

Girl Called Johnny

We Will Not Be Lovers

November Tale

Rosalind (You Married The Wrong Guy)

Three Day Man

Nearest Thing To Hip

I Can See Elvis

Song Of Wandering Aengus

Whole Of The Moon

Don’t Bang The Drum

Long Strange Road

Fisherman’s Blues


Waterboys on David Letterman the previous evening doing “The Girl Who Slept For Scotland”:

For more information on Mike Scott, The Waterboys and Connor Kennedy see:

Album Review: The Prodigy – The Day Is My Enemy

There are few musical guilty pleasures like a new album from The Prodigy. Sadly The Day Is My Enemy does not offer much more than that.  It’s not a bad album, there’s just nothing new here. On the plus side there’s been no mellowing with age; The Prodigy are still hard as nails 25 years down the line.

Most of the tracks are of the hard edged dance variety that you would expect from this band.  Opening track The Day Is My Enemy sets the tone – it sounds like a chainsaw – and that ferocity pretty much lasts for the duration of the album. No doubt these songs will still go down a storm at the summer festivals.

There are a couple of high points – Rhythm Bomb is gloriously old school and Beyond The Deathray sounds like it would be a brilliant live opener that would have a crowd whipped into a frenzy before the beats kick in. The low point is Nasty, which sounds like a Prodigy parody (yes, even more so than Firestarter or Smack My B**** Up!)

The Prodigy were groundbreaking once, but it’s been a long long time since they could claim that. So the wait for another Music For The Jilted Generation continues – not only one of the best dance albums ever made, but one of the best in any genre. While they may never reach those heights again, hats off to them for sticking with it and never compromising.

Score: 6 suns out of 10


Normally at this point there would be a link to something from the new album, but here’s an oldie instead.

Ferocious or what!

Album Review: The Waterboys – Modern Blues

Mike Scott and company release their freshest album since Fisherman’s Blues with a focus on sharply-observed lyrics and accessible tunes

Mike Scott and The Waterboys are one of music’s most enigmatic and interesting acts. In their three decade career going back to their 1983 eponymous debut, Waterboys (and Scott solo) albums are always marked by intricate, poignantly poetic lyrics combined with outstanding musicianship.

On their first three albums (The Waterboys, 1984’s A Pagan Place and 1985’s This Is The Sea) the Waterboys were often grouped together in with U2, Big Country, The Alarm and Simple Minds in what was called the Big Music movement (after a song on A Pagan Place). More a convenience for journalists than a conscious music collective, the description fit though and stuck through the 1980s; these five bands were writing songs based on Big Ideas of spirituality, politics and the politics of love in a complex, soaring, anthemic way that was in another universe than the vapid pop of the day. The music was uplifting, the singing was passionate, the lyrics were mind-expanding and no band exemplified this spirit better than the Waterboys, culminating for me with one of the 10 best songs of the 1980s, This Is The Sea’s “The Whole Of The Moon”.

After this opening trilogy of albums, Waterboys founding member Karl Wallinger (late of World Party) and others departed the band, and Scott and the Waterboys relocated to Ireland and took a hard right turn into a more rustic Celtic style for the stone-cold classic 1988 album Fisherman’s Blues and its raggle-taggle followup, 1990’s Room To Roam. This was an extremely fertile time for the now-sprawling combo as shown by the magnificent six-disc version (!) of Fisherman’s Blues released in 2013 that showed the depth of the work that they were doing in that period. This version of the band is one of my favorite groups of all time.

In 1991 Scott broke up this version of the Waterboys (as he is want to do from time to time), moved to New York and essentially restarted the band from scratch, with a more conventional rock electric sound that continues on to this day with a focus on exquisite word play and a harder-edged sound starting with 1993’s Dream Harder.

In the 22 years since Dream Harder, Scott has released two major solo albums and by my count eight studio Waterboys albums that have all been consistently high quality additions to the catalogue and solidify Scott’s place as one of the great writers of the rock era bringing to mind comparisons to Dylan and Morrison (Van, not Jim).

I admit that from time to time as Scott has delved deeper and deeper into literary allusions and mystic references, he sometimes has gone so deep as to risk losing even some of his devoted fans like me. For every accessible album like 1997’s solo Still Burnin’ or 2007’s Book Of Lightning, there are more impenetrable albums like 2003’s Universal Hall or 2011’s An Appointment with Mr. Yeats, (based on the poetry of William Butler Yeats) that are carefully crafted but so personal to Scott that I personally find them to be difficult listening. At his most obscure, the literary allusions, location references and mystic quotes that I understand only highlight how much of his writing that I don’t understand. I’m convinced that Scott is a lyrical genius even if I don’t understand the half of what he’s on to.

Live, Scott and the Waterboys are one of the most interesting bands going. I’ve seen them probably a dozen times over the years and no two shows have been the same. More than most musicians, Scott channels his muse in his live shows and it can be a remarkable experience to witness. I’ve seen Scott rapturous, expansive, mercurial and funny on stage, and I’ve also seen him angry and churlish; but, never anything other than absolutely authentic.

At their best live, it is as if each musician is not playing their own instruments, but rather the instruments of the other band members around them. It’s hard to explain, but startling to watch, particularly as they play within rhythms, melodies and tempos within a single song. It’s what every jamband aspires to, but the Waterboys at their best are effortless at at it. Their Washington DC show in the weeks after 9/11 was maybe the most empathic show I’ve ever seen both within a band and between a band and an audience.

On their Fall 2013 US tour, I was delighted to hear some new songs and a new direction in their music, which brings us to the nine songs on their excellent new album Modern Blues, released in the US on 2015-04-07.

Recorded in Nashville with American session musicians and long-standing musical ally Steve Wickham on violin, Modern Blues is Scott’s most consistently successful album in years, rating with the best work in his canon.

Modern Blues shines the spotlight on some of the sharpest, most observant and incisive lyrics of Scott’s long career. The music serves to support and highlight the lyrics, and the lyrics demand to be heard. They are more personal and less literary (and thus more universal) than much of Scott’s recent work; they really are more like poems set to music than traditional rock songs.

More than just the words themselves it is the way that Scott enunciates, pronounces and accents the words shows the exacting and precise placement of the writing. There’s not a single sloppy or excess word, even though some of the couplets are stuffed to the brim.

Released in the US a week after Courtney Barnett’s Sometimes I Sit And Think And Sometimes I Just Sit, Modern Blues is an interesting counterpoint. Barnett seems to work hard to have a spontaneous stream-of-conscious, nearly throw-away style to her lyrics that belies the obvious care and craft that she’s put in, whereas with Modern Blues Scott let’s you see the meticulous, crafted brilliance he’s employed throughout.

Whether it’s a quick line like his description of Elvis Presley as “razor-quiffed and leather-squeezed, sideburns flickering in the breeze” in his vision of musicians and famous figures mixing together in the afterlife in I Can See Elvis, or the extended excellence of “The Girl Who Slept For Scotland”, each song has at least one lyrical sequence that pops out to you as you hear it.

“The Girl Who Slept For Scotland” is a sly, lyrical standout from start to finish. Based on the light-hearted title and chorus, it sounds like sort of a throwaway until you hear his description of a sexual tryst:

“…When we sang in tongues together and our synchronized guitars

Played music to the rafters and made love among the stars

And our bodies beat like light in love’s beautiful embrace

As her tiny kisses burst like popping suns around my face

But then drift, recline, collapse, the lights went out, she fell asleep again

Before my kiss-wet face was even dry”

Or try this verse I’m picking at random from the first single, Beautiful Now”:

 “Look down a carousel of years and darling there you are

A Dancer crying salty tears, a Vagabond, a Star

The Slayer of Mediocrity, of every sacred cow

You were beautiful then, sweet angel

You’re way more beautiful now”.

However, before you think that this is one of Those Difficult Albums That Are Hard Work To Listen To, this is actually perhaps the most accessible Waterboys album musically since Fisherman’s Blues. Whether it’s the up-tempo romp of the opener “Destinies Entwined”, the mid-tempo ballad “November Tale”, the jaunty and self-deprecating “Still A Freak”, the doo-wop vocals and handclaps of “I Can See Elvis”, or the gentle slow-dance elegy of “Nearest Thing To Hip”, this is inviting and entertaining music.

Beautiful Now” is probably the most poppy and dare I say radio-friendly single from Scott in years, with a bouncy beat, organ and backup vocals over an innocuous hook and melody that rewards repeated listening. In a more just world, this would be a hit on Adult Alternative Radio in the US.

Before I nominate Scott for sainthood, I personally didn’t think that “Long Strange Golden Road” needed the sample of Jack Kerouac reciting from “On The Road”, and I personally found the kissoff to a romantic rival in “Rosalind (You Married The Wrong Guy” to be too vitriolic to be appealing on repeated listens.

However, these are minor quibbles in what is otherwise a thoroughly enjoyable, likable album from start to finish, and for me it’s bound to be one of the notable albums of the year.

The album is scheduled to be on streaming services in the US as of 2015-04-07, but in the meantime you can find the album as a YouTube streaming playlist at:

Mr. Scott – feel free to continue making Big Music for the next three decades as well. I know that you never went away, but welcome back anyway.

Download: “Beautiful Now”, “The Girl Who Slept For Scotland”. Score: 9 Suns out of 10.